All Reviews
Ryan Moseley
2 months agoBrooklyn Pizza in Crestview is an absolute GEM. It has officially become our favorite pizza place, and I don’t say this lightly — it’s the best pizza I’ve ever had in my life. From the very first bite, you can tell everything is made with care and quality ingredients. The crust is perfectly balanced — crisp on the outside, soft and chewy inside, with that authentic, foldable, New York-style perfection. The sauce tastes bright and fresh, not overly sweet or heavy. The cheese? Flawless. Perfect melt, perfect stretch, perfect flavor. And can we talk about how fresh everything tastes? Even the SALAD is incredible. The greens are always crisp, the toppings are fresh and vibrant, and nothing ever tastes like it’s been sitting around. You can genuinely taste the difference. Every single time we go, it’s consistent. Hot, fresh, flavorful, and clearly made with pride. It’s rare to find a place where you leave thinking, “That was perfect,” but Brooklyn Pizza does it every time. Crestview is lucky to have this place. If you haven’t tried it yet, you are seriously missing out. We’re customers for life.
Melissa Villa
2 months agoEverytime! I come here its always amazing. Between the people, the customer service! And dont get me started on how this is the best pizza in 3 countries!!
Miranda Caron
4 months agoWe LOVE this pizza 🍕 always good, everyone is always nice even when they're busy as can be really helpful. We 95% of the time get take out but it's comfortable if you want to eat inside and always very clean. We go at least once a week during the summer and we've never had a bad experience, been getting pizza from them for over 3 years now
Michaya Berry
4 months agoCustomer service was great, I went with a friend. The gentleman were very humorous and polite. Food was also really good
Britney Green
5 months agoMe and my husband have been wanting to find a good spot for pizza. This place was it! The garlic knots are chefs kiss! We were dining in and I believe the owner was the one bringing our pizza and checked up on us. Very friendly and welcoming. I would recommend this place to anyone.
Amber McCurdy
8 months agoHighly recommend this place. First, the staff and owners were absolutely lovely. The food was great, with generous portions. We had lasagna, a loaded pizza, garlic knots, cannoli, and brownies. Absolutely no complaints, only compliments. Will for sure go back, and family in the area have a new go to. Thank you for such a nice time!
Amanda Bullington
8 months agoThey have some really delicious pizza here! I'll have to come back soon to get more! We had the Brooklyn All Meat pizza and it was so good! Cooked fresh and brought out to our table we could hardly wait for it to cool enough to get a bite.
Trevor Burke
Edited 8 months agoWe brought a party of eight to this pizza place, including three picky kids, and I wasn’t sure if they’d be able to find something they liked. As soon as we arrived, the staff quickly adjusted tables to accommodate our group and made us feel right at home. The servers were incredibly friendly and patient, answering all of our questions with a smile—no small feat considering our party size! The prices were surprisingly reasonable, especially for the generous portions we received. The food was delicious, the servings were huge, and the atmosphere stayed warm and welcoming throughout our entire visit. We left with full stomachs, happy kids, and nothing but great things to say about this place. Highly recommend!